Dissertation Project by Dennis Kirstein
Summary of dissertation project Individual learning with cooperative experimental tasks in chemistry teaching at secondary level I
What?
The goal of the project is to identify and describe key principles for measures and strategies aimed at providing individualized support during experiments in chemistry.
As part of the project, the use of collaborative experimental tasks (Rumann, 2005; Walpuski, 2006; Wahser, 2007; Knobloch, 2011; Emden, 2011; Habig, 2017) on various topics was examined. In this process, individual learning paths and difficulties are analyzed and ultimately related to learning prerequisites and learning conditions.
Why?
In light of the increasingly diverse learning prerequisites of students (see the 2015 PISA study and the 2012 IQB cross-state comparison), teaching and learning have become a complex area of activity within the school setting. In this context, the implementation of individualized support is frequently discussed and, not least, called for against the backdrop of inclusive school development. Open and cooperative forms of learning—characterized by a high degree of alignment between individual learning prerequisites and learning opportunities—are described as particularly significant for the implementation of individualized support in subject-specific instruction (Helmke, 2013; Klieme & Warwas, 2011). Although initial findings on differentiation and individualized instruction in chemistry classes on specific topics are already available (e.g., Puddu, 2017; Anus, 2015; Kallweit, 2015; Groß, 2013), little is known so far about specific principles for individualized support during experimentation, even though experimentation plays a key role in learning within science education (Wirth et al., 2008). Furthermore, the findings in this context primarily relate to high school learning groups; consequently, little is known about the use of individualized learning settings in other types of schools. How students of varying ability levels learn individually through open-ended and cooperative experimental tasks, and how their performance depends on their individual learning prerequisites and the composition of the learning groups formed, has been studied only to a limited extent thus far.
How?
The project is based on a combination of qualitative and quantitative data. These data are collected in the context of cooperative experimental tasks from the content areas “Air and Water,” “Acids, Bases, and Salts,” and “Electrical Energy from Chemical Reactions” in the second year of chemistry at all types of lower secondary schools in North Rhine-Westphalia. Using paper-based tests with multiple-choice items, the data captures prior knowledge (in-house test development & project by Kübra Celik), basic cognitive skills (Heller & Perleth, 2000), knowledge of scientific inquiry methods (Koenen, 2014; Mannel, 2009), and affective factors (Fechner, 2009) are assessed and evaluated using item response theory (IRT) (Boone et al., 2014). To gain insights into how participants approach the experimental tasks, the experimental phases are videotaped, and the learning process is analyzed using qualitative content analysis (Mayring, 2015) to identify individual learning activities and difficulties. Finally, the results from the video analysis are correlated with performance data at the individual and small-group levels as part of a correlation study